Search people, articles, bills, and more
The House rejected an amendment to H.R. 4639, a bill designed to stop government agencies from buying personal data from private brokers without a warrant.
This vote was on a proposed change (an amendment) to the Fourth Amendment Is Not For Sale Act. The main bill aims to close a legal loophole that allows law enforcement and intelligence agencies to purchase sensitive information—such as cell phone location data—from commercial data brokers without the warrant or court order usually required by the Fourth Amendment. This specific amendment sought to modify the rules or scope of those restrictions. In the House of Representatives, an amendment vote is a way for members to adjust the text of a bill before it is finalized. Think of it like a group of people editing a document together: before they vote on the final version, they vote on specific edits or additions. This amendment required a simple majority of those present to pass. The amendment failed to pass, meaning the proposed changes will not be included in the final version of the bill. While a majority of Republicans supported the amendment, a significant group of 55 Republicans joined nearly all Democrats to defeat the measure. The House will continue to consider the main bill in its current form.
The House will move forward with additional amendments or a final vote on the passage of H.R. 4639.
Why it matters. This vote highlights the ongoing debate in Congress over balancing national security and law enforcement needs with the privacy rights of Americans in the digital age.
Who’s affected. U.S. Citizens: The rejection of the amendment keeps the current, stronger privacy protections in the main bill intact. · Federal Law Enforcement: Agencies must continue to operate under the assumption that stricter data-purchasing limits remain part of the legislative goal. · Data Brokers: The vote signals continued congressional interest in regulating how their databases are used by the government.
Democrats. Democrats were almost entirely united in their opposition to this specific amendment.
Republicans. Republicans were split, with about three-quarters of the caucus supporting the change and one-quarter opposing it.
The House rejected an amendment to H.R.
4639, a bill designed to stop government agencies from buying personal data from private brokers without a warrant.
An amendment is a proposal to add, remove, or change parts of a bill. This vote was to decide whether this specific change should be incorporated into the larger piece of legislation.
The House will move forward with additional amendments or a final vote on the passage of H.R. 4639.
This vote highlights the ongoing debate in Congress over balancing national security and law enforcement needs with the privacy rights of Americans in the digital age.
While most Republicans supported the amendment, a bipartisan coalition of nearly all Democrats and a sizable minority of Republicans voted to defeat it.
Democrats were almost entirely united in their opposition to this specific amendment.
Republicans were split, with about three-quarters of the caucus supporting the change and one-quarter opposing it.
The single independent member voted in favor of the amendment.