Search people, articles, bills, and more
The Senate rejected a procedural motion by Senator Hassan to send H.R. 1 back to the Finance Committee for revisions. The motion failed 48-52, keeping the bill on the Senate floor for further consideration.
This vote was on a 'Motion to Commit' regarding H.R. 1. Senator Maggie Hassan proposed sending the bill to the Senate Committee on Finance with specific instructions to change certain parts of the legislation. Such motions are often used by the minority party or a group of senators to suggest alternative language or to delay the progress of a bill they oppose in its current form. In the Senate, a motion to commit is a procedural tool that asks the chamber to stop floor debate and return the bill to a specialized committee. If it had passed, the bill would have left the Senate floor and returned to the Finance Committee, which handles taxes and revenue, to be rewritten according to the instructions in the motion. The motion was rejected by a close margin, with senators from both parties appearing on both sides of the vote. Because the motion failed, H.R. 1 remains before the full Senate, where members can continue to debate, offer other amendments, or move toward a final vote on passing the bill itself.
The Senate will continue its process on H.R. 1, which may include further amendments, debate, or a final vote on the bill itself.
Why it matters. This was a significant procedural hurdle for H.R. 1. The narrow defeat of the motion indicates that a small majority of the Senate prefers to keep the bill moving forward on the floor rather than reopening it for committee-level negotiations.
Who’s affected. Legislators: Senators seeking to rewrite the bill in the Finance Committee were unsuccessful, keeping the focus on the current floor debate.
Democrats. The Democratic caucus was divided, with 25 members voting against the motion and 20 voting in favor.
Republicans. The Republican caucus was nearly evenly split, with 26 members voting against the motion and 25 voting in favor.
On the Motion (Hassan Motion to Commit H.R. 1 to the Committee on Finance with Instructions)
Jun 30, 2025
The Senate rejected a procedural motion by Senator Hassan to send H.R.
1 back to the Finance Committee for revisions. The motion failed 48-52, keeping the bill on the Senate floor for further consideration.