Search people, articles, bills, and more
The House passed the District of Columbia Judicial Nominations Reform Act of 2025, which would give the President direct power to nominate local D.C. judges.
This bill, known as H.R. 5125, proposes a significant change to how judges are selected for local courts in the District of Columbia. Currently, an independent local commission screens candidates and provides a shortlist to the President. This bill would eliminate that commission and allow the President to nominate anyone they choose for these judicial roles, subject to Senate confirmation, similar to how federal judges are appointed. In the House of Representatives, a 'vote on passage' is the final step to approve a bill before it is sent to the Senate. This specific vote required a simple majority to pass, meaning the bill needed more 'yes' votes than 'no' votes among the members present. The bill passed by a narrow margin of 218 to 211, with the outcome following strict party lines. All Republicans who voted supported the measure, while all voting Democrats opposed it. The bill now moves to the Senate for consideration. If it passes there and is signed by the President, it would fundamentally shift the appointment process for D.C.'s local legal system.
The bill has been received in the Senate, where it will be assigned to a committee for review or scheduled for a floor debate and vote.
OPEN BILL →Why it matters. This bill changes the balance of power regarding D.C.'s local legal system, potentially making judicial appointments more political by removing a nonpartisan local vetting step.
Who’s affected. Residents of the District of Columbia: The judges presiding over their local criminal and civil cases would be selected via a different, more politically-driven process. · The President of the United States: Would gain direct authority to select judicial nominees for D.C. local courts without being restricted by a commission's shortlist. · D.C. Judicial Nomination Commission: This independent body would be entirely abolished, ending its role in vetting local judges.
Democrats. The Democratic caucus was united in opposition, with all 211 voting members casting 'no' votes.
Republicans. The Republican caucus was united in support, with all 217 voting members casting 'yes' votes.
On Passage
Sep 17, 2025
The House passed the District of Columbia Judicial Nominations Reform Act of 2025, which would give the President direct power to nominate local D.C.
judges.
This was a final vote on the passage of the bill in the House of Representatives. To move forward, the bill required a simple majority of those present and voting.
The bill has been received in the Senate, where it will be assigned to a committee for review or scheduled for a floor debate and vote.
This bill changes the balance of power regarding D.C.'s local legal system, potentially making judicial appointments more political by removing a nonpartisan local vetting step.
The vote was a strict party-line split, reflecting a clear ideological divide over D.C. local governance and executive power.
The Democratic caucus was united in opposition, with all 211 voting members casting 'no' votes.
The Republican caucus was united in support, with all 217 voting members casting 'yes' votes.
The single independent member voted in favor of the bill.