Senate fails to end debate on the amendment to require voters to provide photo identification
On the Cloture Motion S.Amdt. 4732 to S.Amdt. 4420 to S. 1383 (No short title on file)
MAR 26, 2026 · 1:07 PM ET
CLOTURE ONS.Amdt. 4732Require voters to provide photo identificationMAR 26, 2026 · 1:07 PM ET
FAILED
53–47
A party-line vote. 7 votes short of the 60 needed.
A yes on cloture only ends debate. It is not a vote to pass the bill.
WHAT IS CLOTURE →READ THIS RIGHT
A yes on cloture only ends debate. It is not a vote to pass the bill.
WHAT IS CLOTURE →45 DEM2 IND53 REP
YEANAYCROSSEDTAP A SEAT
WHAT WAS DECIDED
What the Senate was voting on
IN PLAIN WORDS
The Senate voted on whether to end debate on S.Amdt. 4732 to S.Amdt. 4420 to S. 1383. The amendment would make certain Department of Veterans Affairs or Defense photo cards valid voter ID, delay the federal photo-ID rules’ effective date until one day after enactment, and change a date reference for Election Assistance Commission guidance. S. 1383 would require documentary proof of citizenship to register and photo ID to vote in federal elections. Cloture was rejected, with supporters 7 votes short of the 60 needed.
A YES MEANT
End debate on S.Amdt. 4732 to S.Amdt. 4420 to S. 1383 and move to a final vote.
A NO MEANT
Keep debating S.Amdt. 4732 to S.Amdt. 4420 to S. 1383; this is not a vote against the amendment itself.
THE AMENDMENT · S.Amdt. 4732
Require voters to provide photo identification
Defines valid military ID to include photo cards issued by the Department of Veterans Affairs or Defense and delays the federal voter photo-ID rules’ effective date until one day after enactment.
WHERE IT STANDS · WHAT’S NEXT
Passed both chambers; the House on Feb. 11, 2026. Next it goes to the President.
WHY IT NEEDED 600 VACANT · 100 SWORN
60is three-fifths of the 100 senators sworn in. Cloture needs three-fifths of sworn senators, not of those voting.
- SINCE 1975
- Cloture on bills has needed three-fifths. Before that it took two-thirds of those voting.
- 2013, 2017
- Nominations dropped to a simple majority. Bills did not.
- VP
- The Vice President can break ties on simple-majority votes, not on cloture.
60 is three-fifths of the 100 senators sworn in. Cloture needs three-fifths of sworn senators, not of those voting.
- SINCE 1975
- Cloture on bills has needed three-fifths. Before that it took two-thirds of those voting.
- 2013, 2017
- Nominations dropped to a simple majority. Bills did not.
- VP
- The Vice President can break ties on simple-majority votes, not on cloture.
HOW EACH SIDE VOTED
A straight party-line voteStraight party line.
22NDParty-line Senate vote in March
8 FAILEDCloture votes that failed in the Senate in March
243RDCloture vote in the Senate this Congress
THE FULL ROLL
All 100 senators, by stateAll 100 senators
100 SHOWNTAP A NAME FOR DETAILS
100 SHOWN
- Katie Boyd BrittR-ALYEA
- Tommy TubervilleR-ALYEA
- Lisa MurkowskiR-AKYEA
- Dan SullivanR-AKYEA
- Ruben GallegoD-AZNAY
- Mark KellyD-AZNAY
- John BoozmanR-ARYEA
- Tom CottonR-ARYEA
- Alex PadillaD-CANAY
- Adam B. SchiffD-CANAY
- Michael F. BennetD-CONAY
- John W. HickenlooperD-CONAY
- Richard BlumenthalD-CTNAY
- Christopher MurphyD-CTNAY
- Lisa Blunt RochesterD-DENAY
- Christopher A. CoonsD-DENAY
- Ashley MoodyR-FLYEA
- Rick ScottR-FLYEA
- Jon OssoffD-GANAY
- Raphael G. WarnockD-GANAY
- Mazie K. HironoD-HINAY
- Brian SchatzD-HINAY
- Mike CrapoR-IDYEA
- James E. RischR-IDYEA
- Tammy DuckworthD-ILNAY
- Richard J. DurbinD-ILNAY
- Jim BanksR-INYEA
- Todd YoungR-INYEA
- Joni ErnstR-IAYEA
- Chuck GrassleyR-IAYEA
- Roger MarshallR-KSYEA
- Jerry MoranR-KSYEA
- Mitch McConnellR-KYYEA
- Rand PaulR-KYYEA
- Bill CassidyR-LAYEA
- John KennedyR-LAYEA
- Susan M. CollinsR-MEYEA
- Angus S. King, Jr.I-MENAY
- Angela D. AlsobrooksD-MDNAY
- Chris Van HollenD-MDNAY
- Ed MarkeyD-MANAY
- Elizabeth WarrenD-MANAY
- Gary C. PetersD-MINAY
- Elissa SlotkinD-MINAY
- Amy KlobucharD-MNNAY
- Tina SmithD-MNNAY
- Cindy Hyde-SmithR-MSYEA
- Roger F. WickerR-MSYEA
- Josh HawleyR-MOYEA
- Eric SchmittR-MOYEA
- Steve DainesR-MTYEA
- Tim SheehyR-MTYEA
- Deb FischerR-NEYEA
- Pete RickettsR-NEYEA
- Catherine Cortez MastoD-NVNAY
- Jacky RosenD-NVNAY
- Maggie HassanD-NHNAY
- Jeanne ShaheenD-NHNAY
- Cory A. BookerD-NJNAY
- Andy KimD-NJNAY
- Martin HeinrichD-NMNAY
- Ben Ray LujánD-NMNAY
- Kirsten E. GillibrandD-NYNAY
- Chuck SchumerD-NYNAY
- Ted BuddR-NCYEA
- Thom TillisR-NCYEA
- Kevin CramerR-NDYEA
- John HoevenR-NDYEA
- Jon HustedR-OHYEA
- Bernie MorenoR-OHYEA
- Alan ArmstrongR-OKYEA
- James LankfordR-OKYEA
- Jeff MerkleyD-ORNAY
- Ron WydenD-ORNAY
- John FettermanD-PANAY
- David McCormickR-PAYEA
- Jack ReedD-RINAY
- Sheldon WhitehouseD-RINAY
- Lindsey GrahamR-SCYEA
- Tim ScottR-SCYEA
- Mike RoundsR-SDYEA
- John ThuneR-SDYEA
- Marsha BlackburnR-TNYEA
- Bill HagertyR-TNYEA
- John CornynR-TXYEA
- Ted CruzR-TXYEA
- John R. CurtisR-UTYEA
- Mike LeeR-UTYEA
- Bernie SandersI-VTNAY
- Peter WelchD-VTNAY
- Tim KaineD-VANAY
- Mark R. WarnerD-VANAY
- Maria CantwellD-WANAY
- Patty MurrayD-WANAY
- Shelley Moore CapitoR-WVYEA
- James C. JusticeR-WVYEA
- Tammy BaldwinD-WINAY
- Ron JohnsonR-WIYEA
- John BarrassoR-WYYEA
- Cynthia M. LummisR-WYYEA
THE JOURNEY
Every vote on S. 1383, in both chambersPassed the House. Stalled in the Senate.
CHAMBER CONTRASTThe House passed it 218–213 on Feb. 11, with 1 Democrat voting yes. The Senate failed to end debate on it 53–47 on March 26, 7 short of the 60 needed.
MAR 26SENATE#73Cloture on S.Amdt. 4732THIS VOTEFAILED53–47
MAR 24SENATE#68Motion to tableAGREED TO53–47MAR 24SENATE#67Motion to tableAGREED TO53–47MAR 21SENATE#61Cloture on the billFAILED41–49MAR 21SENATE#60Cloture on S.Amdt. 4421FAILED49–41MAR 21SENATE—Cloture motion filedFILED
MAR 19SENATE—Cloture motion filedFILED
MAR 17SENATE#57Motion to proceedAGREED TO51–48FEB 11HOUSE#69On passagePASSED218–213FEB 11HOUSE#68Motion to recommitFAILED214–217FEB 11HOUSE#62On the rule (H.Res. 1057)AGREED TO216–215FEB 11HOUSE#61Previous question on the rule (H.Res. 1057)AGREED TO216–214DEC 18SENATE—Passed by unanimous consentPASSED
DEC 2SENATE—Reported by Senator Moran with an amendment in the nature of a substituteREPORTED
HOUSE · FEB 11
218–213
PASSED · NEEDED 216
1 Democrat voted yes
SENATE · MAR 26
53–47
FAILED · NEEDED 60
IN THE SENATE · DEC 2 – 18
- DEC 2Reported by Senator Moran with an amendment in the nature of a substituteREPORTED
- DEC 18Passed by unanimous consentPASSED
SENT TO THE HOUSE
IN THE HOUSE · FEB 11PASSED 218–213
- FEB 11#61Previous question on the rule (H.Res. 1057)AGREED TO216–214
- FEB 11#62On the rule (H.Res. 1057)AGREED TO216–215
- FEB 11#68Motion to recommitFAILED214–217
- FEB 11#69On passagePASSED218–2131 Democrat voted yes
IN THE SENATE · MAR 17 – 26PENDING
- MAR 17#57Motion to proceedAGREED TO51–48
- MAR 19Cloture motion filedFILED
- MAR 21Cloture motion filedFILED
- MAR 21#61Cloture on the billFAILED41–49
- MAR 24#67Motion to tableAGREED TO53–47
- MAR 24#68Motion to tableAGREED TO53–47
- MAR 26#73THIS VOTECloture on S.Amdt. 4732FAILED53–477 votes short of the 60 needed.
IN THE NEWS · 273 STORIESIN THE NEWS
Coverage of this vote and its bill273 stories from 123 outlets
+ 28 OUTLETS NOT RATED
- Raw StoryLEFTJ6er's racial plea for voter suppression bill: 'Trump will be the last white president'
- BreitbartRIGHTExclusive — Rep. Burgess Owens Endorses Ken Paxton for Senate in Texas
- KHOL 89.1 FM9 Republicans vie for Wyoming’s House seat. Friess is the latest
- MediaiteCENTERFox News Host Has a Direct Question for Republican Lawmaker: ‘What Exactly Does Congress Do These Days?’
- Fox NewsRIGHTTrump sued by Schumer, Jeffries over executive order to increase federal involvement in elections
- Fox NewsRIGHTTrump sued by Schumer, Jeffries over executive order to increase federal involvement in elections
- Washington ExaminerRIGHTSydney Gruters, wife of RNC chairman, launches bid for Congress in Florida
- Fox NewsRIGHTSherrod Brown faces heat for backing judge who compared voter ID to racial suppression
- The Gateway PunditRIGHTWATCH: Democrat Congressman Tries to Scaremonger Church Attendees About Voter ID and It Blows Up in His Face
- The AtlanticLEFTThe Anger Trailing Congress Around the Country
- townhall.comRIGHTNancy Pelosi Claims GOP Could Steal 2026 Midterms As Democrats Say Elections Are Completely Secure
- Bangor Daily NewsCENTERLetter: Susan Collins wrong to support SAVE America Act
- townhall.comRIGHTAndy Barr's Desire for a Mitch McConnell Statue Has Come Back to Haunt Him
- NOTUSCENTERThe Trump Administration Won’t Rule Out the Possibility of Federal Agents at Polls
- VotebeatDespite the SAVE America Act stalling, Trump is reshaping election policy in many states
- Fox4newsCENTERCPAC endorses Ken Paxton in Texas Senate runoff against John Cornyn
- Fox4newsCENTERTed Cruz speaks at CPAC in Texas
- townhall.comRIGHTHouse Republicans Are Reportedly Furious Over the Senate Bill Funding DHS
- The Daily BeastLEFT'Upset' Mike Johnson's Wild Meltdown at MAGA Reps Exposed
- The New RepublicLEFTLauren Boebert Hit With Brutal Fact-Check on Airport Chaos
- townhall.comRIGHTWait, Did Bill Maher Agree With This GOP Rep About Trump's Iran Strikes?
- New York PostRIGHTSenate confirms Sen. Markwayne Mullin to replace Kristi Noem as Homeland Security secretary
- redstate.comRIGHTMorning Minute: Brian Schatz, the Runaway
- pjmedia.comRIGHTWhat Hakeem Jeffries Actually Said About ICE Will Leave You Speechless
- VictorygirlsblogRIGHTTrump Offers Up Deal For SAVE America Act And DHS Funding
- townhall.comRIGHTKen Paxton Returns Fire With a New Ad Targeting John Cornyn
- ABC NewsCENTERGOP Sen. Tillis says objectives of Iran war unclear: 'It's a real problem'
- Next News NetworkRIGHTEXPOSED: Democrat Senator BLOCKS Voter ID Bill After Party Claims They Support Election Security
- Fox NewsRIGHTConnecticut Dems demand IDs to recycle cans but reject GOP efforts to verify citizenship at polls
- Fox NewsRIGHTRep Boebert rejects call for another $200 billion to fund Iran war, while Americans 'can’t afford to live'
Lean describes the outlets, not the vote.
READERS · 0 COMMENTS
What readers think
What do you think?
0 votesDiscussion
Loading comments...
SHARE AND SOURCES
