Megyn Kelly accuses GOP Rep. Randy Fine of going 'full bigot' with post about Muslims
Fine's post comparing Muslims to dogs drew criticism, and he responded to those challenging him.

SOURCE CHECK
TAP FOR WHYCredibility rates Yahoo News, which republished this story. The other scores rate the article itself.
Yahoo News is an established national news publisher, and this page carries material associated with The Hill. The short article identifies an author and includes direct quotations, though the page provides little reporting beyond the public posts and statements.
- Source type — An established national news platform, though the article appears to carry another outlet's reporting.
- Author attribution — A named author is listed.
- Transparency — The page identifies Nexstar copyright and directs readers to The Hill, but does not show an original-story URL.
- Editorial standards — The text attributes statements to their speakers and quotes the relevant social-media posts.
The article quotes Fine's post and responses from Kelly and Jeffries, and gives limited information about possible consequences. It does not include a fuller explanation from Fine or a response from Republican leaders, leaving the account brief and reliant mainly on public statements.
HOW WE SCORE ↗The article includes Fine's original post and subsequent replies, but most of the remaining account is criticism of his remarks. It gives little context from Fine or Republican leaders beyond the posts themselves.
- Counterarguments presented — Fine's posts are included, but no developed explanation or defense is presented.
- Source diversity — The account quotes Kelly, Jeffries and Fine's posts, but is weighted toward critics of Fine.
- Omitted context — The piece offers little broader context about the dispute or the Republican response.
- Loaded language — Loaded language appears in attributed quotations rather than as the article's own characterization.
The article reports Fine's post, the public criticism it drew and the calls for accountability in straightforward news language. The quoted criticism is forceful, but the piece does not add an explicit editorial judgment.
- Language tone — The article uses direct quotations for inflammatory language and otherwise maintains a reportorial tone.
- Framing — It centers the exchange and the response to Fine's post without arguing for a political position.
- Source selection — It includes Fine's post and replies alongside criticism from Kelly and Jeffries.
Republished with credit
Republished from The Hill, with credit to the original publisher.
417 stories · 77.6–78.2 · updated Oct 14, 2026
This is The Hill's own score, and this article is credited to The Hill. The host score in the Source Check is Yahoo News's.
Megyn Kelly criticized Rep. Randy Fine after he posted a comparison of Muslims to dogs and doubled down when challenged. Democratic leaders called for accountability, including possible censure.
Fine wrote that if forced to choose, “the choice between dogs and Muslims is not a difficult one.” After Kelly criticized the post, Fine replied to her, and Kelly accused him of attacking Muslims rather than addressing a person or policy. Fine also posted a dog image in response to criticism from pollster Mark Mitchell.
House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries condemned Fine’s remarks and urged Speaker Mike Johnson to do the same. The article says other members called for Fine to be censured; a censure could cost him committee assignments.
Community verdict
6 VOTESCounts every outlet’s report of this story. See all 29
- Readers of left-leaning coverage: 20% good look
- Readers of right-leaning coverage: not enough votes yet
Votes cast on this page
Votes cast on this page: ▲ 0 · ◆ 0 · ▼ 0
People in this story
SWIPE →Speaker of the House whom Jeffries urged to condemn Fine's post
House Minority Leader who rebuked Fine and called for accountability
Part of a bigger story
17 OUTLETSFine posted a comparison favoring dogs over Muslims and faced criticism, including Democratic calls for resignation, censure or other consequences. Left-leaning outlets and center outlets both focus on criticism and calls for consequences; left-leaning outlets more explicitly frame the remarks as anti-Muslim rhetoric and challenge the later dog-related bill. Center outlets generally report the backlash, with some including Fine’s defense. Right-leaning outlets present Fine’s response and dog-related bill sympathetically and cast Democratic criticism as political opposition.
- ARTICLES
- 29
- OUTLETS
- 17
- AVG CRED
- 67
- CounterPunch.org · Dog Fight in New York: Rep Randy Fine's Latest Attack on American Muslims
- Middle East Eye · Civil rights group sues anti-Muslim Congressman Randy Fine for blocking US citizen on X
- South Florida Sun Sentinel · Jewish Republican Randy Fine draws sharp criticism after suggesting he prefers dogs to Muslims
Discussion · 0
Loading comments…


