GOP Senator's Atlanta Hawks, Iowa Hawkeyes Mix-Up Backfires On Attempt To Catch Jack Smith In A Lie Tied To Fani Willis
Schmitt accused Jack Smith of lying about attending an Atlanta basketball game, then defended his questioning after the mistaken identification was challenged.
SOURCE CHECK
TAP FOR WHYYahoo News is an established national news publisher, but the page gives no byline and the text does not identify who reported or originally published this article. The strongly editorialized presentation also makes it difficult to assess the reporting standards behind this specific piece.
- Source type — An established national news publisher, though Yahoo carries material from multiple sources.
- Author attribution — No author is identified in the page information.
- Editorial standards — The publisher is recognizable, but the article’s original newsroom and standards are not identified.
The article describes a specific hearing exchange and quotes several participants and commentators, but its reporting is one-sided and repeatedly uses evaluative language. It provides little independent documentation for the claims and does not include a substantive response from Schmitt beyond his defense of the questioning.
HOW WE SCORE ↗The article gives extensive criticism of Schmitt’s accusation and includes a brief account of his defense, but it does not provide a meaningful explanation of the basis for his questioning or a substantive response from him. Its language is openly evaluative.
- Counterarguments presented — Schmitt’s defense is mentioned, but not developed or explored.
- Loaded language — The article repeatedly uses disparaging descriptions and presents its own judgment of the exchange.
- Source diversity — The article quotes Smith, Klobuchar and online commentators, but provides little substantive countervailing perspective.
The article frames the exchange as an embarrassing, baseless attack on Smith and places it within a broader critique of Republicans and Trump allies. Its language and selection of reactions strongly favor that interpretation.
- Language tone — Uses strongly judgmental descriptions of Schmitt’s questioning and its outcome.
- Framing — Connects the exchange to a broader claim that Republicans attack Trump’s opponents despite facts.
- Source selection — Quotes critics and commentators, without substantial defense or context from Schmitt.
At a Senate hearing, Eric Schmitt accused Jack Smith of lying about being at an Atlanta Hawks game, but Smith said he had attended an Iowa Hawkeyes game in Maryland. Amy Klobuchar backed up the correction, and the article reports that Schmitt later defended his questioning.
At a Senate hearing, Eric Schmitt questioned former special counsel Jack Smith about whether he had attended an Atlanta Hawks game on February 3, 2024, and accused him of lying. Smith said he had attended a University of Iowa women’s basketball game in Maryland; Amy Klobuchar and her staff confirmed that account and suggested Schmitt had confused the Hawks with the Hawkeyes.
The article says Schmitt defended his questioning and did not apologize, including in a later appearance on The Charlie Kirk Show. It also recounts criticism of Smith by other Republicans, including Ted Cruz, and describes the separate Georgia election-interference case led by Fani Willis.
Community verdict
8 VOTES
People in this story
SWIPE →Senator who accused Jack Smith of lying during a Senate hearing
Senator who supported Smith’s account and challenged Schmitt’s accusation
Former attorney general who appointed Smith as special counsel
President whose opponents and investigations are discussed as background
Senator whose reaction to Schmitt’s questioning is described
Senator who criticized Smith’s investigation during the hearing
Part of a bigger story
21 OUTLETSAt a Senate Judiciary hearing, Eric Schmitt questioned Jack Smith over whether Smith had attended an Atlanta Hawks game. The exchange turned on a mix-up with an Iowa Hawkeyes game Smith said he attended. Left-leaning outlets treat the mix-up as a failed political gotcha and, in some coverage, part of a broader Republican effort to target Smith. Center outlets likewise stress the error and its fallout for Schmitt, with some highlighting the exchange’s viral reactions. Right-leaning outlets also emphasize the accusation’s collapse, with attention to Katie Britt’s viral reaction and, in one column, Schmitt’s political ambitions.
- ARTICLES
- 39
- OUTLETS
- 21
- AVG CRED
- 68
- RadarOnline · Jimmy Kimmel Roasts 'Dumb' Sen. Eric Schmitt After He Accidentally Exposed Jack Smith as a Caitlin Clark Fan in Attempted Takedown
- Alternet.org · The ominous 3-word warning everyone missed in the chaotic Jack Smith hearing
- The New Republic · Eric Schmitt’s a Joke. The Assaults on Jack Smith Are Anything But.
Discussion · 0
Loading comments…