Now Hasan Piker Is Crying Defamation From Democrat 'Israel First Congresswoman' Who Called Him Out
Scholten criticized Piker's comments about Jeremy Moss and answered his accusation that she was defaming him.

SOURCE CHECK
TAP FOR WHYTwitchy is rated 38 by the site's prior-story assessment and is recorded as a blog. The page names an author, but its mocking language and reliance on social-media posts rather than independent verification limit confidence in its editorial standards.
- Track record — The publisher's supplied rating is 38, based on 95 stories.
- Source type — Recorded as a blog, which is a weaker institutional prior than an established newsroom.
- Author attribution — An author is named, though only as Brett T.
- Editorial standards — The page uses mocking language and does not independently verify the allegation it repeats.
The article reproduces social-media statements and provides some context, but it relies heavily on selected posts and commentary. It does not independently verify the allegation about Scholten or offer a substantial range of perspectives.
HOW WE SCORE ↗The piece includes statements from the people involved, but its own language is strongly opinionated and its selected audience reactions largely reinforce one side. It does not independently assess the disputed allegation about Scholten.
- Loaded language — Uses derisive phrasing and a loaded label for Scholten.
- Counterarguments presented — Includes Piker's criticism of Scholten, but does not develop or verify his allegation.
- Source diversity — Relies on statements and selected social-media responses, with little independent sourcing.
- Omitted context — Provides no independent context or verification for the alleged scandal referenced by Piker.
The article uses openly derisive language toward Piker and frames the exchange in terms favorable to opposition to his views. Its headline and closing appeal also signal a strong partisan orientation.
- Language tone — Uses mocking descriptions and dismissive commentary about Piker.
- Framing — Presents criticism of Piker as laudable and treats his response as a grievance.
- Headline — The headline uses a pejorative label for Scholten and a dismissive characterization of Piker.
- Source selection — Includes selected social-media reactions that largely criticize Piker.
Hasan Piker criticized Rep. Hillary Scholten after she spoke out about his comments targeting Michigan Senate candidate Jeremy Moss; Piker accused her of defaming him. Abdul El-Sayed also issued a statement distancing his campaign from Piker's comments.
The article says Piker commented that American Jews who support Israel were worsening antisemitism and that someone might eventually take action against them, while singling out Jeremy Moss. Scholten issued a statement criticizing Piker's remarks. Piker responded by accusing her of defaming him and referring to an alleged possible scandal; the article provides no verification of that allegation. Scholten replied that Piker, not she, was hurting Democrats' chances. [cite only via ids]
Community verdict
2 VOTESPeople in this story
SWIPE →Michigan representative who criticized Hasan Piker's comments about Jeremy Moss and responded to Piker's accusation of defamation.
Michigan Senate candidate singled out by Piker's comments.
President mentioned in the editor's note about the 2026 midterms.
Senate candidate who issued a statement clarifying that Piker does not speak for his campaign.
Part of a bigger story
3 OUTLETSScholten criticized Hasan Piker over comments about Michigan Senate candidate Jeremy Moss. Right-leaning outlets present Scholten’s condemnation as the central response; they differ in how much they include Piker’s response and reactions from others.
- ARTICLES
- 3
- OUTLETS
- 3
- AVG CRED
- 58
Discussion · 0
Loading comments…



