Graham Platner's personal journey is important for Maine
The letter argues that voters should consider Platner’s recovery and later choices alongside his old Reddit posts.
SOURCE CHECK
TAP FOR WHYCredibility rates Portland Press Herald, which carries this article. The other scores rate the article itself. Portland Press Herald's published outlet score.
Credibility rates Portland Press Herald, which carries this article. The other scores rate the article itself. Portland Press Herald's published outlet score.
HOW WE SCORE ↗The letter presents a clear, coherent argument and identifies its author, but relies on the author's account and offers no supporting documents, independent sources or response from the Mills campaign.
HOW WE SCORE ↗The letter advances a defense of Platner and criticism of the Mills campaign without presenting the campaign's explanation or a competing account. It briefly acknowledges that the old posts were mistakes.
- Counterarguments presented — No response or rationale from the Mills campaign is included.
- Opinion vs reporting — The piece is an openly argumentative letter rather than an independently reported account.
- Loaded language — The author characterizes the campaign's decision as a political calculation and urges voters not to dismiss Platner.
The letter clearly favors Platner over the Mills campaign, but it does not take a discernible position on left-right policy issues.
- Framing — The piece argues for weighing Platner's later actions against his old posts, but both candidates are Democrats and no policy dispute is discussed.
- Language tone — The language supports Platner's personal growth and criticizes the campaign's decision, without invoking a broader ideological position.
Also carried by
The same article also appears on Centralmaine.com and 1 other site. Which outlet published it first has not been determined.
In a letter, David Harvey argues that Graham Platner’s personal growth after struggling with depression and PTSD deserves consideration alongside his old Reddit posts. He criticizes the Mills campaign for reviving the posts without acknowledging what Platner did afterward.
David Harvey, identifying himself as a former Janet Mills voter, says he is disappointed that the Mills campaign revived decade-old Reddit posts by Graham Platner. Harvey says Platner addressed the posts, explained their context and apologized when they surfaced the previous October, and that his campaign has continued to gain support since.
Harvey says Platner wrote the posts after combat tours in Iraq and Afghanistan, while struggling with depression and PTSD. He says Platner sought help through the VA, rebuilt his life and chose to run for public office, arguing that voters should weigh that subsequent growth and accountability alongside his past mistakes.
Community verdict
8 VOTESCounts every outlet’s report of this story. See all 12
Votes cast on this page
Votes cast on this page: ▲ 0 · ◆ 0 · ▼ 0
People in this story
SWIPE →Maine Senate candidate whose past Reddit posts and subsequent personal journey are discussed
Maine Senate candidate whose campaign is criticized for reviving Platner’s old posts
Part of a bigger story
7 OUTLETSJanet Mills’ campaign has run ads criticizing Graham Platner over past online comments, and Platner has responded with ads of his own. The dispute is unfolding as they compete for the Democratic Senate nomination in Maine. Left-leaning outlets emphasize an argument that voters should weigh Platner’s personal growth and later choices alongside the posts, criticizing Mills’ campaign for reviving them. Center outlets focus on the competing ads and campaign strategy, also examining voter support and the ads’ claims. Right-leaning outlets foreground the controversy around Platner’s posts and Mills’ ads; one also presents Warren’s endorsement as contentious.
- ARTICLES
- 12
- OUTLETS
- 7
- AVG CRED
- 68
- Wgme · Truth Tracker: Breaking down two dueling ads from Janet Mills, Graham Platner
- The Maine Wire · Mills Campaign Unleashes Emotional Ad Featuring Army Veteran Who Calls Platner 'Unacceptable' Over Past Reddit Comments
- NBC News · Janet Mills and Graham Platner battle for female voters in Maine's key Senate race
Discussion · 0
Loading comments…

