Good Riddance, Seth Moulton: You Got What You Deserved
Bacon presents Moulton’s primary loss as a warning against distancing Democrats from their base after an election defeat.
SOURCE CHECK
TAP FOR WHYThe New Republic is an established national publication with editorial standards and attributed authorship. This article is explicitly polemical opinion rather than straight news reporting, which limits the weight readers should place on its analysis as neutral reporting.
- Source type — Established national publication; the article itself is opinion commentary.
- Author attribution — A named author is identified.
- Editorial standards — A recognizable publication with editorial oversight, though this piece is openly argumentative.
The piece identifies its author and includes a quotation attributed to an outside source, along with specific election and voting claims. Its argument is strongly one-sided, however, and it offers little opposing perspective or independent substantiation for several evaluative claims.
HOW WE SCORE ↗This is an opinion column that makes a sustained case against Moulton and Democrats who supported the Laken Riley Act. It acknowledges some counterpoints, such as the difficulty of defeating an incumbent, but does not substantially present the targets’ responses or competing interpretations.
- Opinion vs reporting — The headline and argument are explicitly opinionated rather than neutral reporting.
- Counterarguments presented — Briefly notes that defeating an incumbent is difficult, but gives little space to contrary arguments.
- Source diversity — Includes one outside quotation but otherwise relies primarily on the author's analysis.
- Loaded language — Repeatedly uses judgmental language to characterize the people and positions discussed.
The article advances an explicitly progressive argument, praises progressive policy positions, and condemns Democrats it portrays as moving right or capitulating to Trump. Its language and framing are strongly left-leaning.
- Framing — Frames post-election movement to the right as a mistake and progressive politics as the preferable alternative.
- Language tone — Uses openly condemnatory language about Moulton and other Democrats, including describing his loss as deserved.
- Source selection — Relies on a progressive activist’s criticism and highlights progressive endorsements and policies.
Perry Bacon argues that Seth Moulton’s loss to Senator Edward Markey in the Massachusetts Democratic primary shows that distancing Democrats from their base after the 2024 election can backfire. He links the result to Moulton’s comments on transgender athletes and compares it with Angie Craig’s loss after voting for the Laken Riley Act.
Bacon argues that Moulton wrongly blamed Democrats’ 2024 defeat on being too far left and drew criticism for comments about transgender athletes. He says Moulton’s subsequent complaints about that criticism and his challenge to Markey ended in a decisive primary loss, which Bacon presents as a warning to Democrats who distance themselves from the party’s base. Bacon also says Markey appealed to progressives through his support for policies including Medicare for All and the Green New Deal.
Bacon contrasts Moulton with lawmakers he considers stronger advocates for progressive policies and against Trump. He also argues that Craig’s vote for the Laken Riley Act contributed to her Senate primary loss, noting that Minnesota’s lieutenant governor criticized her vote. Bacon concludes that Democrats who moved right after the 2024 election were politically vulnerable, though he says most of the lawmakers who supported the act remain in Congress.
Community verdict
12 VOTES
People in this story
SWIPE →Representative and unsuccessful primary challenger to Edward Markey
Incumbent senator who defeated Moulton in the Democratic primary
Markey's version of this story ↗
Representative criticized by Bacon as an example of the kind of Democrat he does not want elevated
President and political figure in the article’s discussion of Democrats’ response to his election
Representative criticized by Bacon as an example of the kind of Democrat he does not want elevated
Former president discussed in connection with Harris’s campaign and the 2024 election
Senator praised by Bacon as a progressive fighter
Representative and unsuccessful Senate primary candidate cited as a parallel example
Former presidential candidate whose 2024 defeat provides context for the article’s argument
Minnesota lieutenant governor who criticized Craig’s vote
Representative identified as a supporter of Markey
Representative cited as an example of younger leadership and as a Markey supporter
Senator praised by Bacon as a progressive fighter
Part of a bigger story
2 OUTLETS- ARTICLES
- 2
- OUTLETS
- 2
- AVG CRED
- 75
Discussion · 0
Loading comments…