O'Donnell Compares GOP Senator To 'Drunk McCarthy,' Insists Trump Has Dementia
O’Donnell criticized Schmitt’s questioning of Jack Smith and compared him to Joe McCarthy.

SOURCE CHECK
TAP FOR WHYNewsBusters is an opinion-oriented, ideologically aligned outlet, which lowers confidence in its framing. The article identifies its author and includes a transcript of the remarks it discusses, but provides limited independent reporting or context.
- Source type — Opinion-oriented and strongly aligned in its framing.
- Transparency — It includes a transcript of the broadcast remarks central to the story.
- Author attribution — The article names its author.
- Editorial standards — The article offers little independent verification or context beyond the transcript.
The article supplies a transcript of O’Donnell’s remarks, allowing readers to check its central quotations. It does not provide Schmitt’s account or substantive context about the hearing, and it relies largely on one-sided presentation of the exchange.
HOW WE SCORE ↗The piece reproduces O’Donnell’s comments but provides little context from the hearing or response from Schmitt, and its narration frames O’Donnell’s remarks critically. The included transcript offers evidence of what was said, but not competing perspectives on the underlying events.
- Source diversity — The article centers on one commentator’s remarks and includes no substantive response from Schmitt.
- Omitted context — It does not explain what Schmitt asked at the hearing or provide the underlying material in question.
- Loaded language — Its narration repeatedly describes O’Donnell as attacking or targeting the people he discusses.
- Opinion vs reporting — The article’s framing is critical rather than a detached account of the dispute.
The article uses skeptical and critical language about O’Donnell’s remarks and includes a reminder of Newsbusters’ criticism of MS NOW’s own journalism claims. Its selection and framing favor the targets of O’Donnell’s criticism.
- Language tone — Uses terms such as “mocking,” “went after,” and “target” to characterize O’Donnell’s comments.
- Framing — Presents the remarks as aggressive attacks and emphasizes the claims about drinking and dementia.
- Omission — Does not provide a substantive account of the hearing or O’Donnell’s rationale.
- Headline — Highlights the most inflammatory comparisons and allegation.
NewsBusters reports that Lawrence O’Donnell criticized Sen. Eric Schmitt’s questioning of Jack Smith and compared him to Joe McCarthy, then suggested President Donald Trump’s comments about midterm prospects reflected either pathological lying or dementia.
The article says O’Donnell criticized Schmitt’s questioning of former special counsel Jack Smith at a Senate hearing, calling him the Senate’s “new Joe McCarthy” and speculating about whether he had been drinking. O’Donnell also said Schmitt did not look drunk, but compared his performance to a “drunk Joe McCarthy at his worst.”
The article reports that O’Donnell then cited Trump’s remarks that Republicans had strong numbers and “should win” the midterms, and said they could reflect pathological lying or dementia. It also notes that Trump had previously joked that he had never drunk alcohol.
Community verdict
7 VOTESCounts every outlet’s report of this story. See all 51
Votes cast on this page
Votes cast on this page: ▲ 0 · ◆ 0 · ▼ 0
People in this story
SWIPE →Senator whose questioning of Jack Smith was criticized by Lawrence O’Donnell
President whose midterm comments O’Donnell cited
Part of a bigger story
21 OUTLETSAt a Senate Judiciary Committee hearing, Eric Schmitt questioned Jack Smith about whether Smith attended an Atlanta Hawks game and accused him of perjury. Amy Klobuchar said Schmitt may have confused the Hawks with the Iowa Hawkeyes; Smith had attended an Iowa-Maryland game in Maryland. Left-leaning outlets frame the exchange as Schmitt's mistaken accusation and emphasize his continued defense and the political fallout. Center outlets focus on the team confusion and criticism, with some connecting it to Schmitt's political profile. Right-leaning outlets split: one presents Schmitt's questions as catching Smith, while the other foregrounds Lawrence O'Donnell's criticism of Schmitt.
- ARTICLES
- 51
- OUTLETS
- 21
- AVG CRED
- 64
Discussion · 0
Loading comments…


