James Talarico is forcing Ken Paxton to air his dirty laundry
Talarico is seeking to unseal depositions given by his Senate opponent Ken Paxton.

SOURCE CHECK
TAP FOR WHYDaily Kos is rated 43 by the site across 105 stories, and its blog source type is a strong reason to score below established news organizations. This page identifies its author and attributes some reporting to other outlets, but its argumentative language and limited sourcing do not provide a reason to depart from the publisher rating.
- Track record — The site's rating is 43 across 105 stories, indicating a comparatively limited institutional credibility record.
- Source type — Recorded as a blog, a source type that merits a lower prior than established newsrooms.
- Author attribution — The page names Lisa Needham as its author.
- Editorial standards — The article has an overtly argumentative tone, with no visible corrections or standards information in the supplied text.
The article identifies the motion and cites reporting by The Washington Post and The Wall Street Journal, and it includes a response from Paxton’s spokesperson. However, it is highly opinionated, offers little detail about the underlying case or the motion, and presents several damaging claims without supporting documentation in the article.
HOW WE SCORE ↗The story includes Paxton’s spokesperson’s response and attributes earlier reporting to other outlets, but the article is structured as an argument against Paxton and offers little context about the case or the reasons the depositions might remain sealed.
- Counterarguments presented — Paxton’s spokesperson is quoted, but the response is brief and immediately rebutted by the author.
- Loaded language — The article repeatedly uses emotionally charged and derogatory language about Paxton.
- Source diversity — It references two news outlets and quotes a spokesperson, but does not provide substantial competing perspectives.
- Omitted context — The supplied text gives limited detail about the lawsuit, the motion’s legal basis, or the sealing rationale.
The article strongly favors Talarico’s effort and uses openly hostile language about Paxton, while dismissing Paxton’s response rather than presenting it as a competing position. The framing and word choice indicate a strong left lean.
- Language tone — Uses insulting and derisive language about Paxton and approving language about Talarico.
- Framing — Frames the motion as a justified transparency effort and challenges Paxton to permit unsealing.
- Source selection — Includes one brief response from Paxton’s spokesperson but does not develop a defense of Paxton’s position.
James Talarico filed a motion seeking to make public two depositions Ken Paxton gave in connection with a lawsuit involving Unity Resources. The article argues Texans should be able to see Paxton’s sworn statements and criticizes his response to the effort.
The article reports that James Talarico filed a motion to unseal depositions Ken Paxton gave in 2019 and 2022 in a case connected to Paxton’s work with Unity Resources. It says the Wall Street Journal previously reported that Paxton likely violated attorney-client privilege by turning over a former client’s communications; Paxton called that report “blatant lies,” according to the article.
Paxton’s spokesperson, Madison Cercy, said the motion was an attempt to hide Talarico’s extremism. The article challenges that response and argues Paxton could agree to unseal the depositions. It also recounts other allegations and controversies involving Paxton and reports that Karl Rove described the Senate race as a toss-up.
Community verdict
2 VOTESPeople in this story
SWIPE →Democratic Senate candidate who filed the motion to make Paxton’s depositions public
Republican Senate candidate whose depositions Talarico is seeking to unseal and whose prior conduct the article criticizes
Paxton's version of this story ↗President mentioned in a report that he might intervene in the Texas Senate race
Senator whose primary race against Paxton is mentioned as context for prior reporting on the deposition
Part of a bigger story
8 OUTLETSTalarico’s campaign asked a court to unseal depositions Ken Paxton gave in a securities dispute, arguing voters should be able to review them before the Senate election. Left-leaning outlets frame the request as transparency for voters, with Daily Kos taking a more openly approving tone. Center outlets place the filing in the Senate race context and also track polling and Paxton’s vulnerabilities. Right-leaning outlets frame Talarico’s puppy-themed criticism of Paxton’s animal-welfare record as a campaign-messaging contest.
- ARTICLES
- 8
- OUTLETS
- 8
- AVG CRED
- 72
- NBC 5 Dallas-Fort Worth · Ken Paxton depositions could be unsealed in Texas Senate race – NBC 5 Dallas-Fort Worth
- San Antonio Current · Talarico campaign asks court to unseal Paxton's depositions in energy investing dispute
- Winnipeg Free Press · Talarico wants to unearth Paxton's depositions to keep focus on opponent's past in Texas Senate race
Discussion · 0
Loading comments…


