Fire 'nasty' parliamentarian? No; The Senate is part of 'a club,' and the president's not in it – World Tribune: U.S. Politics and Culture, Geostrategy, China, North Korea, Corporate Watch, Media Watch
Trump publicly demanded that Thune fire MacDonough and criticized her rulings.
SOURCE CHECK
TAP FOR WHYThe page identifies its publisher and attributes the piece to its staff, but offers little sourcing beyond a quoted social-media post and uses highly evaluative language. Its institutional standards and corrections record are not established by the article.
- Source type — Recorded as national news, though this article is strongly opinionated in its wording.
- Editorial standards — The article gives little independent sourcing or evidence beyond the quoted post and its own assertions.
- Author attribution — Attributed to WorldTribune Staff, with no individual reporter identified.
- Transparency — The page identifies the outlet but does not establish correction practices or reporting methods.
The article explains the basic Senate procedure and reproduces Trump’s post, but relies on assertions and an openly hostile characterization of senators. It provides little independent sourcing, response, or context for the senators’ actions.
HOW WE SCORE ↗The piece presents Trump’s demand and a brief explanation of reconciliation rules, but it does not include responses from the parliamentarian or the senators criticized. Its language is openly disparaging.
- Counterarguments presented — No response from the criticized senators or parliamentarian is included.
- Loaded language — The article calls senators “ancient” and “codgers” and describes the Senate as the “Swamp.”
- Source diversity — The main quoted source is Trump’s social-media post; no independent or opposing sources appear.
- Omitted context — It gives limited explanation of the senators’ reasons or the procedural details behind the rulings.
The piece favors advancing the SAVE America Act and uses disparaging language about the senators and Senate leadership portrayed as impeding it. Trump’s criticism of the parliamentarian is reproduced at length without a counter-response.
- Language tone — Uses labels such as “ancient,” “codgers” and “Swamp” to disparage Senate figures.
- Framing — Frames the senators and parliamentarian as obstacles to a measure the article says voters overwhelmingly support.
- Source selection — Quotes Trump’s attacks at length but includes no response from MacDonough or the senators criticized.
- Headline — The headline presents the Senate as a club that excludes the president, reinforcing the article’s anti-establishment framing.
A World Tribune analysis says President Donald Trump wants Senate Republicans to fire Parliamentarian Elizabeth MacDonough over rulings affecting the SAVE America Act, but Majority Leader John Thune has not done so. It also criticizes several Republican senators for keeping the measure from a floor vote.
The analysis says Trump has pushed for the SAVE America Act, which it describes as requiring voter ID and proof of citizenship to vote in federal elections. It presents MacDonough’s rulings on reconciliation provisions, Thune’s refusal to fire her, and four Republican senators’ recent actions to keep the bill from reaching the Senate floor as obstacles to the measure.
The article quotes Trump calling MacDonough “nasty” and a “Radical Left Lunatic,” and demanding that she be replaced. It also explains that reconciliation can allow certain budget-related measures to bypass the Senate’s 60-vote threshold, subject to procedural limits enforced by the parliamentarian.
Community verdict
15 VOTESPeople in this story
SWIPE →President urging Senate Republicans to fire the parliamentarian
Senate Majority Leader who has not acted on Trump’s demand to fire the parliamentarian
Thune's version of this story ↗Senator named among Republicans who joined Democrats to keep the act from a floor vote
Senator criticized for retaining MacDonough and named among the Republicans who kept the act from a floor vote
Senator named among Republicans who joined Democrats to keep the act from a floor vote
Senator named among Republicans who joined Democrats to keep the act from a floor vote
Discussion · 0
Loading comments…





