Maine MAGA Candidate Paul LePage Complains About Family Member's ICE Deportation
Paul LePage criticized a relative’s deportation while saying ICE should focus on gang members and criminals.
SOURCE CHECK
TAP FOR WHYThe Daily Beast is an established national news outlet, and this article has a named author and reports statements from the candidate, DHS and an attorney. The excerpt does not provide enough information to assess the outlet’s corrections practices or the underlying evidence independently.
- Source type — Established national news publisher; a reasonable prior for professional editorial standards.
- Author attribution — The article names its reporter.
- Transparency — It attributes key claims to LePage, DHS and an attorney, while identifying information it says remains unknown.
The article includes direct quotations and attributes claims about the deportation and shooting to the people or agencies making them. It gives relevant context about LePage’s prior support for ICE, but the excerpt offers limited independent documentation and little direct response from ICE or DHS to the specific allegations about the shooting.
HOW WE SCORE ↗The article presents LePage’s statements and DHS’s explanation, along with claims from an attorney representing the victim’s family. However, the account of the shooting relies on those competing statements without much additional independent evidence or detail from DHS.
- Counterarguments presented — DHS’s public-safety explanation and its claim about Guerrero’s vehicle are included alongside the family attorney’s statements.
- Source diversity — The article includes the candidate, DHS and an attorney, but few independent sources are represented.
- Omitted context — The excerpt provides limited detail on the evidence underlying the competing accounts of the shooting.
The report uses critical framing, including “cried foul” and “supposed success,” and gives substantial attention to a fatal shooting and disputed DHS claims. It also includes LePage’s stated position and DHS’s account, but the overall presentation tilts left in its framing of ICE and the candidate’s support for it.
- Language tone — Some phrasing casts LePage’s comments and administration claims skeptically.
- Framing — The article juxtaposes LePage’s support for ICE with his objection to a relative’s deportation and a fatal shooting.
- Source selection — LePage’s remarks and DHS’s stated account appear, alongside an attorney’s account; independent supporting documentation is limited in the excerpt.
Maine congressional candidate Paul LePage criticized the deportation of a relative he said had a work permit while reiterating support for ICE’s work targeting gang members and criminals. The article places his remarks alongside a fatal ICE shooting in Maine and the resulting congressional inquiry.
Paul LePage, a former Maine governor running for Congress, said his son’s father-in-law was in the United States legally but was being deported. LePage said the relative had a work permit and “should be allowed to stay,” but did not identify the man’s country of origin. The article says it is unclear whether he was referring to Devon Raymond, whom LePage previously described as an “adopted son.”
LePage also said immigration officers “have a job to do,” and that he would focus on people in gangs and criminals rather than everyone with work permits. The article notes his earlier support for ICE operations in Maine. It also recounts the July shooting death of Johan Sebastián Durán Guerrero by immigration officers: DHS said the officer fired because of a public-safety concern and later claimed Guerrero had weaponized his vehicle, while an attorney for Guerrero’s family said a bullet struck an empty car seat and that Guerrero’s daughter was not in the vehicle.
Community verdict
20 VOTES
People in this story
SWIPE →Former Maine governor and congressional candidate commenting on a relative’s deportation and ICE enforcement
Vice President who appeared with LePage at a rally
Part of a bigger story
14 OUTLETSMaine congressional candidate Paul LePage said a relative with work authorization is facing deportation and that he believes immigration enforcement should prioritize people with criminal records or gang ties. Left-leaning outlets frame his objection as a contradiction with his support for ICE enforcement. Center outlets report both his objection and his enforcement views, with some adding arrest data, a DHS response or campaign criticism.
- ARTICLES
- 17
- OUTLETS
- 14
- AVG CRED
- 61
Discussion · 0
Loading comments…