Nancy Mace gets brutal reminder from colleague as she pushes 'born in the USA' bill
Mace says her proposed bill would bar naturalized citizens from holding elected office.
SOURCE CHECK
TAP FOR WHYRaw Story is an established digital news outlet with an identifiable author, but its institutional standards and corrections record are less transparent than those of major outlets. This article attributes its central statements to a social-media post and a recorded interview, while offering limited independent reporting.
- Source type — An established digital news outlet, though not a wire service or newspaper of record.
- Author attribution — A named author is credited.
- Editorial standards — The article attributes key remarks, but the short report provides limited sourcing beyond those remarks.
- Transparency — The page identifies the author and publisher, but the article itself provides little information about verification or corrections.
The brief report includes direct quotations and basic context on naturalized citizens' eligibility, but does not provide the proposed bill text, seek Mace's response, or explore the legal and policy arguments on both sides.
HOW WE SCORE ↗The article gives Mace's stated position and basic eligibility context, but its central framing and the other lawmaker's response are critical; no supporter of the proposal or response from Mace is included.
- Counterarguments presented — The article does not present a defense of the proposed restriction.
- Source diversity — The central perspectives are Mace's post and Ramirez's criticism, with no further interview or independent expert.
- Loaded language — The headline uses “brutal,” and the quoted criticism calls the proposal “xenophobic.”
- Opinion vs reporting — It is written as news, but the framing emphasizes criticism of Mace.
The article frames Mace's proposal critically, including a headline calling the response “brutal” and an opening suggestion that she overlooked an important detail. It quotes Mace's statement and Ramirez's criticism but gives little space to arguments supporting the proposal.
- Language tone — The headline and opening use pointed, critical phrasing about Mace.
- Framing — The proposal is presented through the criticism that it overlooks Republicans who were born abroad.
- Source selection — The article quotes Mace's post and a Democratic lawmaker's criticism, without a supporter of the proposal.
Rep. Nancy Mace says her bill would bar naturalized citizens from elected office below the presidency. Rep. Delia Ramirez criticized the proposal, noting that some Republicans were also born outside the United States.
Mace said in a post that people not born in the United States should not hold power in government. The article reports that she is proposing legislation to prohibit naturalized citizens from holding elected office, while noting that naturalized citizens can already run for offices below the presidency after meeting citizenship-duration requirements.
Asked about the proposal, Rep. Delia Ramirez called Mace “racist” and “unstable” and pointed out that some Republicans, including Florida Rep. Carlos Gimenez, were also born abroad. The article says Mace is running in a crowded South Carolina gubernatorial primary.
Community verdict
15 VOTES
People in this story
SWIPE →South Carolina representative proposing a bill restricting naturalized citizens from holding elected office
President mentioned in connection with Mace's gubernatorial primary
Illinois representative criticizing Mace's proposal
Florida representative cited by Ramirez as a Republican born in Cuba
Part of a bigger story
10 OUTLETSOutlets agree Nancy Mace proposed a constitutional amendment restricting naturalized citizens’ eligibility for several federal roles, including Congress. Left-leaning outlets stress criticism of the proposal, including its impact on naturalized lawmakers and possible political costs. Center outlets pair the proposed restrictions with lawmakers’ objections, while varying in how much they include Mace’s rationale. Right-leaning outlets give greater weight to Mace’s rationale and claims about naturalized officials, though some also report criticism.
- ARTICLES
- 10
- OUTLETS
- 10
- AVG CRED
- 60
- Fox News · Nancy Mace introduces amendment requiring natural-born citizens in Congress
- Sean Hannity · Nancy Mace Proposes Constitutional Amendment Requiring Federal Officials To Be Natural-Born Citizens
- The American Bazaar · Krishnamoorthi rebukes proposal restricting naturalized citizens from federal office
Discussion · 0
Loading comments…