Steve Schmidt Turns Lindsey Graham's Death Into a Trump Tantrum
Manney argues that Schmidt’s condemnation of Graham overlooks his military service, family responsibilities and defense of Brett Kavanaugh.

SOURCE CHECK
TAP FOR WHYPJ Media is an opinion-focused publisher, and this article is a named author’s argument rather than independent straight-news reporting. The author is identified and quotes Schmidt’s post, but the piece offers little evidence beyond those quotations and biographical assertions.
- Source type — Opinion-first publisher and explicitly argumentative article.
- Editorial standards — The page provides limited visible evidence of independent reporting or sourcing practices.
- Author attribution — A named author is credited.
- Transparency — The author identifies Schmidt’s Substack as the source of the quoted farewell, but offers limited sourcing for other claims.
The piece gives a clear account of its disagreement with Schmidt and quotes the post it criticizes. It supplies little independent documentation or opposing perspective, and its strongly evaluative language makes it more advocacy-oriented than balanced reporting.
HOW WE SCORE ↗This is a one-sided opinion piece defending Graham and criticizing Schmidt. It quotes Schmidt’s language and acknowledges criticisms of Graham, but does not offer Schmidt’s response or a fuller account of the competing interpretations.
- Counterarguments presented — The author notes Graham’s interventionism and his political reversal, but mainly to defend his broader record.
- Loaded language — Uses strongly evaluative language about Schmidt, Trump and Graham.
- Opinion vs reporting — The article is an argument expressing the author’s view.
- Source diversity — No range of independent sources or responses is presented.
The author uses explicitly conservative language to defend Graham’s record and portrays Schmidt’s criticism as a symptom of anti-Trump bias. The piece frames Graham’s shift toward Trump as a political reversal but presents Trump’s influence in comparatively favorable terms.
- Language tone — Uses dismissive labels such as “Trump Derangement Syndrome” and “congressional critters.”
- Framing — Centers a defense of Graham against a strongly anti-Trump critic.
- Source selection — Relies on Schmidt’s quoted post and the author’s own judgments, with no independent or opposing voices.
- Headline — Frames Schmidt’s response as a “Trump Tantrum.”
David Manney argues that Steve Schmidt’s harsh post about Lindsey Graham after Graham’s death ignores Graham’s military service, family responsibilities and defense of Brett Kavanaugh. The opinion piece also criticizes Graham’s later support for Donald Trump while disputing Schmidt’s condemnation of him.
Manney describes Schmidt’s farewell post as a spiteful attack, quoting Schmidt’s claims that Graham chose Trump over his country and that Trump was Graham’s “rotten legacy.” Manney argues that the post reduces Graham’s life to his political reversal and overlooks his military service, care for his sister after their parents died, and defense of Brett Kavanaugh during the Senate confirmation hearings.
Manney acknowledges Graham’s support for military action and his shift from criticizing Trump to becoming an ally, but says Schmidt’s criticism is disproportionate. The piece also recounts Graham’s criticism of Senate Democrats’ handling of Christine Blasey Ford’s accusation against Kavanaugh, and concludes that Graham’s record should not be reduced to his support for Trump.
Community verdict
VOTING CLOSEDNo good or bad look here
This story reports what happened without casting Graham in a good or bad light, so readers don’t rate it and it doesn’t count toward Graham’s record.
People in this story
SWIPE →President discussed in connection with Graham’s political reversal and Schmidt’s criticism
Then-ranking Democrat on the Senate Judiciary Committee, described as having received Ford’s confidential accusation
Part of a bigger story
52 OUTLETSOutlets agree that Lindsey Graham died, prompting tributes and discussion of his political legacy. Left-leaning outlets focus on criticism of Graham’s foreign-policy record and questions about Trump’s statements and conduct after the death. Center outlets emphasize tributes, the circumstances and consequences of his death, and his foreign-policy influence. Right-leaning outlets emphasize tributes and Graham’s value as an ally to Trump, Republicans and Israel, while also covering the death investigation and online reactions.
- ARTICLES
- 63
- OUTLETS
- 52
- AVG CRED
- 63
Discussion · 0
Loading comments…



