Herald endorsement: U.S. House District 28
The editorial criticizes Giménez’s record on election challenges and immigration while acknowledging his concerns about deportations and his vote to extend TPS for Haitians.

SOURCE CHECK
TAP FOR WHYThe Miami Herald is an established regional newspaper with an identifiable editorial board and a clear distinction between opinion and reporting. This page is explicitly an editorial endorsement rather than independent news reporting.
- Source type — Established local newspaper; a strong regional-outlet prior.
- Editorial standards — The piece is clearly labeled as an editorial-board endorsement, making its advocacy transparent.
- Transparency — The publisher and authoring body are identified.
The editorial provides specific candidate positions and acknowledges weaknesses in both its endorsed candidate and Giménez, but it is an argument for a preferred candidate rather than a balanced report. Some claims are attributed to the candidates or editorial board, with limited competing perspective.
HOW WE SCORE ↗This is an openly persuasive endorsement, not a neutral candidate profile. It does include criticism of Ehr and acknowledges some actions by Giménez, but the editorial’s central purpose is to argue for Ehr.
- Opinion vs reporting — An editorial endorsement presenting the board’s preferred candidate.
- Counterarguments presented — Notes Ehr’s shortcomings and mentions Giménez’s concerns about deportations and TPS vote.
- Source diversity — Includes candidate positions and an attributed comment, but no direct response from Giménez; the board says he did not meet with it.
The editorial favors a Democratic challenger and sharply criticizes Giménez’s alignment with Trump and the administration’s immigration policies. Its preference and critical framing are explicit, as expected in an endorsement.
- Framing — Frames Giménez as insufficiently willing to oppose Trump’s immigration policies and recommends his opponent.
- Language tone — Uses evaluative language such as “Trump acolyte” and says Giménez has not displayed needed leadership.
- Headline — The title identifies the piece as an endorsement, and the editorial explicitly endorses Ehr.
The Miami Herald Editorial Board endorses Phil Ehr over Carlos Giménez in Florida’s 28th Congressional District, criticizing Giménez’s alignment with President Trump and response to immigration policies while noting Ehr’s shortcomings.
The Miami Herald Editorial Board says voters should consider alternatives to Giménez, who is seeking a fourth term, because of the district’s exposure to the effects of Trump’s deportation policies. The board endorses Democrat Phil Ehr, while saying independent candidate Eddy Rojas is not prepared for Congress. It also notes that Ehr has run for Congress before and wants more specific answers on housing prices.
The board criticizes Giménez for supporting efforts to overturn Joe Biden’s 2020 victories in Arizona and Pennsylvania and for not showing sufficient leadership on immigration, while acknowledging that he raised concerns with administration officials and voted to extend Temporary Protected Status for Haitians. Ehr supports stronger border security, opposes deporting Haitians and Venezuelans whose TPS was revoked, and says he opposes the war in Iran. The editorial concludes by endorsing Ehr.
Community verdict
2 VOTESPeople in this story
SWIPE →Incumbent seeking reelection and the subject of the editorial’s criticism
President whose deportation and election-related actions form part of the editorial’s criticism
2020 presidential election winner referenced in connection with Giménez’s vote
Independent candidate in the district race
Discussion · 0
Loading comments…


