‘Slim to None’: Senate Democrats Suggest They Would Block Any Trump SCOTUS Noms for 2 Years if They Win Midterms
Blumenthal said Democratic support for a Trump administration nominee would be “slim to none.”
SOURCE CHECK
TAP FOR WHYMediaite is an established political news outlet with identified authors and reporting, though this short article relies substantially on another outlet’s account and offers limited original sourcing.
- Source type — An established national political news publisher.
- Editorial standards — The piece is presented as news and attributes the underlying report to NBC News.
- Author attribution — The article names an author.
- Transparency — The article identifies its source for the reported comments, but provides little detail about original reporting or corrections.
The article includes direct quotations from several named senators and relevant context about possible vacancies and the 2016 Garland episode. Its short length and reliance on an NBC News report leave little room for independent sourcing or competing Republican perspectives.
HOW WE SCORE ↗The article provides several Democratic senators’ views and historical context, but includes no response or counterargument from Republicans or the Trump administration.
- Source diversity — The article cites an NBC report and quotes multiple Democratic senators, but no opposing source.
- Counterarguments presented — No Republican or administration response is included.
- Loaded language — Strongly worded descriptions are present as attributed quotations rather than the article’s own assertions.
- Omitted context — The article offers limited context on how a future Senate majority might handle nominations beyond the cited precedent.
The article reports Democratic senators’ stated positions in mostly neutral language, while clearly attributing their critical descriptions of Trump’s nominees to them.
- Language tone — The narration is largely matter-of-fact; charged descriptions appear in attributed quotations.
- Source selection — The article centers Democratic senators’ views and does not include a Republican response.
- Framing — The framing presents a possible future confirmation blockade as conditional on Democrats winning Senate control.
- Headline — The headline’s “Slim to None” wording is drawn from an attributed quote.
Senate Democrats Chuck Schumer and Richard Blumenthal said they would be unlikely to support President Donald Trump’s future Supreme Court nominees if Democrats win control of the Senate. Ruben Gallego urged Democrats to follow Mitch McConnell’s 2016 treatment of Merrick Garland’s nomination.
Schumer said blocking Trump from appointing what he called “horrible” justices was one reason Democrats wanted to retake the Senate. Blumenthal said support for a Trump administration nominee was “slim to none,” citing what he described as the record of Trump’s nominees. The article attributes the account to an NBC News report.
The article says the issue could become consequential if a Supreme Court vacancy arises, noting that Justices Samuel Alito and Clarence Thomas are among the court’s oldest members and that neither had announced plans to step down. Gallego said Democrats should do what McConnell did when he declined to consider President Barack Obama’s nominee Merrick Garland in 2016.
Community verdict
23 VOTES
People in this story
SWIPE →Senator arguing that Democrats would be unlikely to support a Trump administration Supreme Court nominee
Senate Democratic leader discussing how Democrats would handle future Trump Supreme Court nominees
Schumer's version of this story ↗
Obama’s Supreme Court nominee whose nomination McConnell declined to consider
President whose future Supreme Court nominees are the subject of the senators’ comments
Former Senate majority leader whose refusal to consider Merrick Garland’s nomination is cited as precedent
Senator urging Democrats to follow Mitch McConnell’s approach to Merrick Garland’s nomination
Part of a bigger story
2 OUTLETSDiscussion · 0
Loading comments…