Lindsey Graham's death leaves the U.S. Senate at a crossroads
Hartmann argues that Graham’s death will test whether Republican senators preserve the Senate’s independence.

SOURCE CHECK
TAP FOR WHYIndependent Australia publishes an explicitly argumentative column by a named author, rather than a reported news account. The page identifies its author and publication, but the article itself provides limited sourcing for its claims.
- Source type — Opinion-led political commentary rather than straight reporting.
- Author attribution — The column names Thom Hartmann and includes an author biography.
- Transparency — The publisher and article page are identified, but no reporting documents or sources are cited.
The column lays out a clear argument and identifies specific institutional questions, but offers little supporting documentation or source attribution and does not present counterarguments. Its evaluative language is prominent.
HOW WE SCORE ↗This is a one-sided opinion column that argues senators should resist Trump’s demands. It does not give space to counterarguments or responses from the people criticized.
- Counterarguments presented — No opposing case for Trump’s proposals or senators’ possible choices is presented.
- Loaded language — Repeatedly uses strongly evaluative language about Trump and Graham.
- Opinion vs reporting — The piece advances the author’s interpretation and recommendation rather than presenting competing accounts.
The column strongly criticizes Trump and Graham and uses language that frames their conduct as servile and damaging to democratic institutions. Its framing is distinctly progressive and anti-Trump.
- Language tone — Uses sharply condemnatory terms such as “grotesque,” “servility” and “pathetic cheering section.”
- Framing — Frames the central question as whether senators will serve the Constitution or the President.
- Source selection — Presents the author’s argument without quoted opposing perspectives.
Thom Hartmann argues that Lindsey Graham’s death leaves Republican senators facing a choice over whether to preserve Senate powers or yield to President Trump. He points to disputes over the filibuster, budget reconciliation, nominations, war powers and Ukraine as tests of the Senate’s independence.
Hartmann says Graham died on July 11 at 71 and accuses Trump of using the death to press the Senate to pass voting legislation and end the filibuster. He describes Graham’s post-2016 record as deference to Trump and says Graham’s death creates uncertainty about the Senate’s future direction.
The column identifies five tests: whether senators retain the filibuster; how Ron Johnson handles the Budget Committee and reconciliation; how the Senate considers nominations and spending bills; whether senators assert war powers and continue support for Ukraine; and whether Republican senators withstand pressure over voting rights. Hartmann urges readers to contact their senators and argues that their choices will determine whether the Senate checks presidential power.
Community verdict
VOTING CLOSEDNo good or bad look here
This story reports what happened without casting Graham in a good or bad light, so readers don’t rate it and it doesn’t count toward Graham’s record.
People in this story
SWIPE →Former U.S. senator whose death is presented as a turning point for the Senate
Former senator mentioned as Graham’s former political compatriot
Senator described as resisting Trump on voting rights
President whose demands and actions are central to the column’s account of pressure on the Senate
Senator described as resisting Trump on voting rights
Senator described as resisting Trump on voting rights
Senator described as resisting Trump on voting rights
Senator expected to take over as Budget Committee chairman
Part of a bigger story
98 OUTLETSOutlets agree that Lindsey Graham died after a sudden illness, as his office reported. Left-leaning outlets connect his death to Senate Republican dynamics, debates over his legacy and, in some coverage, speculation about its circumstances. Center outlets emphasize the reported cause of death, tributes and the distinction between preliminary findings and unsupported online claims. Right-leaning outlets emphasize tributes, the Senate vacancy and effects on Republican priorities, alongside reports on the cause of death.
- ARTICLES
- 128
- OUTLETS
- 98
- AVG CRED
- 67
Discussion · 0
Loading comments…









