Skip to main content
11 min read

Can We Talk About the So-Called Talking Filibuster and Why It Won't Save the SAVE Act?

Patterson argues Thune is avoiding a Senate strategy that could consume weeks or months without passing the SAVE Act.

Can We Talk About the So-Called Talking Filibuster and Why It Won't Save the SAVE Act?
Image · HotAir

SOURCE CHECK

TAP FOR WHY
Outlet credibilityHotAir42/100 LOW
This article1 analysis · Oct 9, 2026
HotAir
Mar 12, 2026
tl;dr

Duane Patterson argues that using prolonged Senate debate under Rule XIX is unlikely to pass the SAVE Act, because amendments and debate could consume too much time and Democrats could continue to resist. He also says the strategy could prevent the Senate from addressing other business, and praises John Thune for not pursuing it.

Community verdict

VOTING CLOSED
How does this story look for
John Thune R · SD · SEN
NOT RATEDCLOSED

No good or bad look here

This story reports what happened without casting Thune in a good or bad light, so readers don’t rate it and it doesn’t count toward Thune’s record.

● INFORMATIONAL

People in this story

SWIPE →
John Thune
R · SD · SEN

Senate majority leader whose handling of the SAVE Act strategy is discussed

PRIMARY SUBJECT
Mike Lee
R · UT · SEN

Senator promoting a strategy to press Democrats to debate the SAVE Act

Lee's version of this story ↗
Christopher Murphy
D · CT · SEN

Senator named as a possible lengthy speaker during debate

Donald Trump
R · President of the United States

President who praised the SAVE Act

John Fetterman
D · PA · SEN

Senator described as unlikely to join a prolonged filibuster

Joe Manchin, III
Former U.S. Senator (I-WV)

Former senator mentioned in a comparison about changing the filibuster

Mazie K. Hirono
D · HI · SEN

Senator used as a hypothetical example of a lengthy speaker

J.D. Vance
Vice President of the United States

Vice President mentioned as a possible replacement for Thune

Kyrsten Sinema
Former U.S. Senator (I-AZ)

Former senator mentioned in a comparison about changing the filibuster

Cory A. Booker
D · NJ · SEN

Senator cited as a hypothetical lengthy speaker and amendment proposer

Part of a bigger story

16 OUTLETS
John Thune Plans Senate Floor Vote on SAVE America Act

Outlets report that John Thune plans to bring the SAVE America Act to the Senate floor and has said a talking filibuster lacks enough support. Left-leaning outlets frame Thune's resistance as a check on Trump and conservative pressure, while treating Punchbowl influence claims as an online theory. Center outlets focus on Senate procedure and Republican divisions over using a talking filibuster. Right-leaning outlets split over whether Thune should use the tactic, with some urging it and others saying it lacks votes or could consume Senate time; some also cover claims of Punchbowl influence.

Discussion · 0

What's your take?

Loading comments…