Graham Platner, Ken Paxton expose both parties' hypocrisy on scandals
Kurtz argues that Democrats are overlooking serious allegations against Platner because he is their candidate.

SOURCE CHECK
TAP FOR WHYFox News is an established national outlet with editorial operations and an identified author, though its partisan reputation warrants a measured score. This is a clearly labeled opinion column, not independent straight-news reporting.
- Source type — An established national news organization, though known for a pronounced political perspective.
- Author attribution — The column identifies Howard Kurtz as its author.
- Editorial standards — The publisher has a formal newsroom, but the page is explicitly opinion rather than reported news.
- Transparency — The piece attributes several claims to named sources and to The New York Times.
The column identifies the sources of several allegations and includes responses and counterexamples, but relies on a strongly argued interpretation, gives limited context for the allegations, and offers little direct representation of the candidates’ full responses.
HOW WE SCORE ↗The column applies its criticism to both parties and includes some defenses and qualifications, but it is an opinion argument rather than a balanced report, and provides limited direct responses or competing context.
- Loaded language — The author uses emphatic judgments, including “sheer, unadulterated hypocrisy” and “utter hypocrisy.”
- Opinion vs reporting — The article is an opinion column that advances the author’s conclusion about political hypocrisy.
- Counterarguments presented — It notes that some Democrats questioned Platner, that some former partners described a good relationship, and that Paxton’s investigation was dropped.
- Source diversity — It cites reporting and quotations but does not develop substantial direct responses from both candidates.
The column criticizes both parties for tolerating scandal, but spends substantial space attacking a liberal Democratic candidate and faulting the press and his Democratic allies. Its overall framing leans right while maintaining criticism of Republicans as well.
- Framing — The column frames party support for scandal-tainted candidates as hypocrisy on both sides.
- Language tone — Loaded phrases such as “all the garbage” and “utter hypocrisy” give the piece an argumentative tone.
- Source selection — The column emphasizes allegations against Platner and criticism of his Democratic allies, while also recounting Paxton’s controversies.
- Headline — The headline expressly casts both parties as hypocritical, tempering the otherwise right-leaning emphasis.
Howard Kurtz argues that Democrats and Republicans tolerate scandals involving their own Senate candidates while condemning similar conduct by the opposing party. He focuses on allegations about Graham Platner and Ken Paxton’s Texas Senate primary win.
Howard Kurtz argues that both parties apply different standards to candidates facing scandal. He criticizes Democrats for supporting Maine Senate candidate Graham Platner despite allegations reported by The New York Times, while noting that Platner disputes some of those accounts. Kurtz also says Platner’s allies have highlighted his military record and populist agenda.
Kurtz compares that response with Republicans’ reaction to Ken Paxton’s Texas Senate primary victory over John Cornyn. He recounts Paxton’s impeachment by the Texas House, a federal investigation that was later dropped, a health care fraud settlement, and an adultery accusation, and argues that Republicans are prioritizing the Senate seat over their stated standards.
Community verdict
9 VOTESPeople in this story
SWIPE →Maine Senate candidate facing scrutiny over allegations about his past conduct
Republican Texas Senate candidate and state attorney general
Paxton's version of this story ↗Democratic Texas Senate candidate who will face Paxton
Republican senator whom Platner hopes to defeat
President who endorsed Paxton
Senate majority leader who backed Cornyn
Senator who campaigned with Platner
Maine governor and former Democratic Senate candidate
Incumbent Texas senator defeated by Paxton in the Republican Senate runoff
Representative who campaigned with Platner and criticized his past behavior
Part of a bigger story
52 OUTLETS- ARTICLES
- 120
- OUTLETS
- 52
- AVG CRED
- 64
Discussion · 0
Loading comments…









