For common sense on Capitol Hill, Paul LePage is not the right guy
Collins argues that LePage’s record and past remarks make him a poor choice for Congress.
SOURCE CHECK
TAP FOR WHYCentralmaine.com is a regional news outlet, which provides a reasonable baseline for editorial standards. This is an attributed, signed opinion column rather than original straight-news reporting, and no page-specific correction or sourcing information is provided.
- Source type — Regional news publisher; a sound baseline but not enough page-specific evidence to rate at the top tier.
- Author attribution — The column identifies its author, Steve Collins, and describes his journalism background.
- Editorial standards — The page is clearly presented as a signed opinion column, distinguishing argument from straight news.
- Transparency — The text supplies attribution for quoted remarks but offers no visible corrections information.
The column identifies the remarks it disputes and gives examples from LePage’s past, but it relies mainly on the author’s judgments and selected historical quotations. It does not include a response from LePage or Johnson or develop opposing perspectives.
HOW WE SCORE ↗This is a one-sided opinion column advocating against LePage and for Dunlap. It quotes Johnson’s praise of LePage but does not offer a substantive defense of LePage or Johnson’s assessment.
- Counterarguments presented — Johnson’s praise is quoted, but no fuller counterargument or response is included.
- Loaded language — The author uses strongly evaluative language about LePage and his candidacy.
- Opinion vs reporting — The page is explicitly a signed opinion column advocating a preferred candidate.
- Source diversity — The argument is largely the author’s own, with limited source diversity.
The column takes an explicitly critical view of Republican figures LePage and Donald Trump while endorsing Democrat Matt Dunlap. Its evaluative language and one-sided argument make it lean left.
- Language tone — Uses pointed judgments about LePage and calls his candidacy and remarks incompatible with common sense.
- Framing — Frames the choice as rejecting LePage and Trump-aligned politics in favor of Dunlap.
- Source selection — Features Johnson’s praise and historical examples critical of LePage, without responses from the criticized figures.
Opinion columnist Steve Collins argues that House Speaker Mike Johnson’s praise of Paul LePage is misplaced and endorses Matt Dunlap as the better choice to represent Maine’s 2nd District. The column cites LePage’s past remarks and Dunlap’s character as reasons.
Steve Collins criticizes House Speaker Mike Johnson for describing Paul LePage as a common-sense candidate and one of the most qualified people to run for the House. Collins argues that LePage’s past remarks and his loss in the 2022 Maine governor’s race undermine that praise.
The column says LePage is competing with state Auditor Matt Dunlap for the chance to represent Maine’s 2nd Congressional District. Collins praises Dunlap’s humor, practicality, decency and energy, and argues that voters should choose him rather than LePage.
Community verdict
3 VOTESPeople in this story
SWIPE →Republican candidate for Maine’s 2nd Congressional District and the central target of the column’s criticism.
Democratic candidate for Maine’s 2nd Congressional District, whom the columnist endorses over LePage.
Dunlap's version of this story ↗
House Speaker who praised LePage’s candidacy.
Former governor cited as an example of a former governor who served in the House.
President criticized by Collins in the column’s closing argument.
Part of a bigger story
2 OUTLETS- ARTICLES
- 2
- OUTLETS
- 2
- AVG CRED
- 61
Discussion · 0
Loading comments…