Susan Collins Outperforms Her 2020 Public Polling
A new poll places Collins behind Graham Platner, but above her public polling levels before her 2020 reelection.
SOURCE CHECK
TAP FOR WHYBreitbart is an established, strongly partisan outlet, and this article names its author and attributes polling claims to identifiable sources. The text offers some poll details but does not show a broad range of independent perspectives.
- Source type — The publisher is recorded as opinion, a strong prior for a partisan, opinion-first outlet.
- Transparency — The article attributes poll findings to named publications and gives sample size, dates and margin of error.
- Author attribution — A named author is identified.
- Source selection — The article relies partly on party and political figures, with limited countervailing perspectives.
The article provides specific polling figures, dates, sample size and margin of error, and attributes findings to the Times/Siena survey. It gives useful historical polling context, but offers little detail about methodology beyond the basic survey information and includes limited competing perspectives on the controversies it discusses.
HOW WE SCORE ↗The article reports polling results that favor each candidate on different measures and gives numerical detail, but its discussion of Platner’s controversies draws on reported allegations and Republican messaging without presenting his response. The historical comparison also largely supports the article’s Collins-focused frame.
- Source diversity — The article cites a named poll and historical polling, but political commentary and party messaging are also prominent sources.
- Counterarguments presented — The poll includes measures favorable to Platner, but no response to the controversies is included.
- Omitted context — The story gives little context about the reported controversies beyond their existence and voter awareness.
- Loaded language — The article is mostly matter-of-fact, though its selection of controversy details creates a tilt.
The article’s focus on Collins’s stronger-than-expected polling and Platner’s controversies presents the race in a way favorable to the Republican incumbent. It includes some poll measures favorable to Platner, but relies in part on Republican messaging and gives little space to a response to the controversy claims.
- Framing — The headline and historical comparison emphasize Collins’s relative strength.
- Source selection — The article includes Republican National Committee messaging and a Trump quote, without a comparable campaign response.
- Omission — Platner’s perspective on the reported controversies is not presented.
- Language tone — Most language is reportorial, with some emphasis on controversy and electoral vulnerability.
A New York Times/Siena poll found Graham Platner narrowly ahead of Sen. Susan Collins in Maine’s 2026 Senate race, though Collins’s 47 percent support exceeded every public poll listed before her 2020 reelection. The poll also found Collins ahead on several personal measures, while Platner led on others.
A New York Times/Portland Press Herald/Siena survey of 608 likely Maine voters, conducted June 19–26, found Graham Platner leading Susan Collins 49 percent to 47 percent. The Times said the two-point difference was too small for polls to measure reliably; the reported margin of sampling error was plus or minus 4.8 percentage points.
The article compares Collins’s 47 percent in the new poll with public polling before her 2020 reelection, when listed surveys put her between 38 and 44 percent. Collins ultimately defeated Democrat Sara Gideon by 51.0 percent to 42.4 percent. The poll also found Collins ahead on character, moral values and bringing resources to Maine, while Platner led on being an independent voice and doing what is best for ordinary Mainers.
The article reports that more than 90 percent of likely voters had heard about controversies involving Platner’s past conduct, and that about 30 percent of his supporters said the reports raised questions about supporting him. It also recounts comments by Democratic lawmakers and former New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo, and a statement by President Donald Trump, about Platner and the race.
Community verdict
VOTING CLOSED
No good or bad look here
This story reports what happened without casting Collins in a good or bad light, so readers don’t rate it and it doesn’t count toward Collins’s record.
People in this story
SWIPE →
President who commented on Democrats and Platner
Democratic candidate who challenged Collins in 2020
Senate Minority Leader who reaffirmed his endorsement of Platner
Senator quoted about the Maine race
Representative quoted about the allegations against Platner
Democratic candidate challenging Collins for Maine's Senate seat
Senator quoted about Platner
Part of a bigger story
9 OUTLETSA poll put Graham Platner two points ahead of Sen. Susan Collins in Maine’s Senate race, 49% to 47%, with the lead within the poll’s margin of error. Left-leaning outlets present the narrow lead as a possible opening for Platner and a warning sign for Collins, while also examining whether Platner’s controversies affect support. Center outlets weigh both candidates’ vulnerabilities and voter priorities in a closely contested race. Right-leaning outlets emphasize Collins’s personal ratings and other relative strengths alongside Platner’s controversies, often casting her position as more resilient than the topline suggests.
- ARTICLES
- 10
- OUTLETS
- 9
- AVG CRED
- 63
Discussion · 0
Loading comments…