Sen. Hagerty Files Bar Complaint Against Jack Smith: 'His Prosecutorial Misconduct Damaged Our Constitutional Order'
Hagerty filed a bar complaint accusing Jack Smith of professional misconduct over a nondisclosure order tied to a subpoena for Hagerty’s phone records.

SOURCE CHECK
TAP FOR WHYBreitbart is a partisan, opinion-oriented publisher, which lowers the institutional score, though the article identifies its reporter and grounds its account in Hagerty’s post and letter. The report does not provide Smith’s response or independent verification of the allegations.
- Source type — Opinion-oriented and partisan publisher; this is a meaningful limitation for institutional credibility.
- Editorial standards — The article attributes key allegations to Hagerty, but offers little independent scrutiny or context.
- Author attribution — A named reporter is credited.
- Transparency — It identifies the post and complaint letter as the basis for Hagerty’s claims.
The article reports the contents of a named senator’s post and complaint letter and generally attributes the allegations to him. It offers considerable detail about the claim but no response from Smith or independent assessment of whether the conduct violated professional rules.
HOW WE SCORE ↗The article gives extensive space to Hagerty’s allegations and rationale but does not include Smith’s response, the board’s position, or independent legal analysis. Attribution clarifies that the claims are Hagerty’s, but the range of perspectives is narrow.
- Counterarguments presented — No response or counterargument from Smith is included.
- Source diversity — The account is based mainly on Hagerty’s post and complaint letter.
- Opinion vs reporting — The story reports the complaint but largely recounts one side’s case.
- Loaded language — Strong language is attributed to Hagerty rather than consistently stated as the article’s own conclusion.
The report foregrounds Hagerty’s accusations and reproduces his forceful language, while providing no response from Smith or alternative account. The framing therefore leans right, although the allegations are attributed to Hagerty.
- Headline — The headline centers Hagerty’s accusation of prosecutorial misconduct and quotes his constitutional-order claim.
- Source selection — The article relies on Hagerty’s post and letter and includes no response from Smith.
- Language tone — Charged claims appear prominently, mostly as direct quotations or attributed assertions.
Sen. Bill Hagerty says he filed a Tennessee bar complaint accusing former special counsel Jack Smith of withholding key information when seeking a nondisclosure order for records subpoenas. Hagerty asks the state board to pursue disbarment, while the article presents his allegations without a response from Smith.
Hagerty said he filed the complaint in a post on X and argued that Smith failed to alert a federal judge to legal protections for congressional communications when seeking a secret order related to a subpoena for Hagerty’s phone records. Hagerty said the nondisclosure order prevented him from challenging the subpoena before Verizon turned over the records.
In the letter, Hagerty asked Tennessee’s Board of Professional Responsibility to investigate and pursue disbarment, alleging that Smith’s conduct harmed Congress and its legislative privileges. The article also reports that Smith testified before the Senate Judiciary Committee and that investigators obtained communications between journalists and Trump administration officials; it does not include a response from Smith.
Community verdict
6 VOTESPeople in this story
SWIPE →President whose federal indictments were brought by Smith
Part of a bigger story
4 OUTLETSHagerty filed a complaint accusing Jack Smith of misconduct over subpoenas for lawmakers’ phone records. Right-leaning outlets frame the filing around allegations of prosecutorial misconduct, with some using the language of lawfare.
- ARTICLES
- 4
- OUTLETS
- 4
- AVG CRED
- 43
- John Locke Foundation · Complaint filed against Jack Smith for lawfare
- WorldNetDaily · 'Serious misconduct': Lawfare orchestrator Jack Smith now being put on defense in disbarment fight * WorldNetDaily * by Bob Unruh
- Thefederalist · Sen. Hagerty Files Bar Complaint Against Jack Smith Over Arctic Frost Lawfare
Discussion · 0
Loading comments…

