Mullin inherits a mess at DHS. Here's how he can still save Trump's legacy.
Howell attributes DHS’s management problems and weak results in part to Noem’s leadership and decisions.

SOURCE CHECK
TAP FOR WHYBlaze Media is an established but strongly ideological outlet, so its institutional credibility is moderated by the need to distinguish its opinion content from independent reporting. The article is transparently labeled as a column and identifies its author.
- Source type — An established national outlet, though its political orientation warrants caution.
- Editorial standards — The page is clearly presented as a column rather than straight news reporting.
- Author attribution — A named author is provided.
- Track record — The article offers limited independent documentation for several of its critical claims.
The column gives concrete examples and attributes one deportation estimate to the New York Times, but many judgments and claims about internal dysfunction, costs and personnel are presented without supporting documents or responses from the people criticized. It offers recommendations rather than competing perspectives.
HOW WE SCORE ↗This is an opinion column advocating for a more effective mass-deportation effort and criticizing Noem’s management. It provides little space for responses from Noem, Trump, or others criticized, and does not present counterarguments to the author’s policy position.
- Counterarguments presented — The column does not set out counterarguments to its preferred deportation agenda.
- Source diversity — Few claims are attributed to sources, and no response from the principal figures criticized is presented.
- Opinion vs reporting — The piece is explicitly an opinion column and advances the author’s prescriptions.
- Loaded language — The author uses pointed and evaluative descriptions of DHS messaging and management.
The column endorses the mass-deportation agenda and presents its success as important to Trump’s legacy. It criticizes perceived obstacles to that agenda in distinctly pro-Trump, anti-left framing.
- Framing — Treats the mass-deportation agenda as a central legacy goal and urges its advancement.
- Language tone — Uses dismissive language about the left and critical language about internal opponents and weak Republican offices.
- Omission — Does not develop arguments from critics of mass deportation or present their perspective.
- Headline — Frames Mullin’s task as saving Trump’s legacy.
Columnist Mike Howell argues that Markwayne Mullin can improve DHS by increasing deportations, distancing the department from Kristi Noem’s tenure, and empowering experienced staff. Howell criticizes Noem’s communications strategy, internal management and handling of contracts, while arguing that the department’s performance matters to Trump’s legacy.
Howell says deportation figures were too low to fulfill Trump’s promise and cites a New York Times estimate of about 230,000 removals in 2025, contrasting it with shifting DHS claims. He criticizes the department’s advertising and messaging, Noem’s centralized contract approvals, delays to border-wall and detention projects, personnel choices, and a $220 million ad campaign that featured Noem. He also describes congressional hearings in which Noem said Trump approved the ad spending; Trump later denied it.
Howell says Mullin inherits a department facing internal conflict, low output and credibility problems. He recommends prioritizing results over messaging, separating Mullin from the prior administration’s controversies, asking Inspector General Joseph Cuffari to review them, and supporting experienced DHS personnel.
Community verdict
VOTING CLOSEDNo good or bad look here
This story reports what happened without casting Noem in a good or bad light, so readers don’t rate it and it doesn’t count toward Noem’s record.
People in this story
SWIPE →Former Secretary of Homeland Security whose tenure is criticized
Senator nominated to lead the Department of Homeland Security
Mullin's version of this story ↗President whose deportation agenda and DHS decisions frame the column
Senator who questioned Noem about the advertising campaign
Part of a bigger story
5 OUTLETSPresident Trump selected Sen. Markwayne Mullin as his choice to replace Kristi Noem as Homeland Security secretary. Left-leaning outlets focus on concerns about Mullin’s abortion and immigration record and compare him with Noem. Right-leaning outlets portray Noem’s management as a problem and Mullin as positioned to improve DHS and advance Trump’s immigration agenda.
- ARTICLES
- 5
- OUTLETS
- 5
- AVG CRED
- 55
Discussion · 0
Loading comments…



