Stephen Miller must be confused about gender identity
The column describes attacks on Talarico and his responses, and defends his comments about God’s gender.

SOURCE CHECK
TAP FOR WHYBaptist News Global is a named, established niche publisher, and the author is identified as its executive director and publisher. This is explicitly an opinion column, so its argument should be distinguished from independent straight-news reporting.
- Source type — Niche publication with a focused religious-news audience.
- Author attribution — The author is named and his role at the publisher is stated.
- Editorial standards — The page is an openly argumentative column rather than neutral reporting.
The column identifies social-media posts and quotes an interview, but relies mainly on the author's assertions and theological argument. It offers little countervailing perspective or independent corroboration of the claims it discusses.
HOW WE SCORE ↗The piece is an openly critical opinion column. It presents Talarico’s responses and the opposing claims, but does not include replies from Miller or Paxton or develop their rationale.
- Opinion vs reporting — The author argues for his own view and makes explicit theological judgments.
- Loaded language — Uses highly charged characterizations of Miller and Paxton.
- Source diversity — Quotes or describes the claims and responses but gives no direct response from Miller or Paxton.
The column uses strongly critical language about Miller, Paxton and Republican claims, while affirming Talarico and his theological position. Its framing is distinctly favorable to Talarico and critical of his Republican opponents.
- Language tone — Uses terms such as “despicable,” “literal Nazi,” “smears” and “lies” for the targets of the column.
- Framing — Presents Talarico as the target of baseless attacks and endorses his theological argument.
- Source selection — Relies on the columnist's account and Talarico's responses, with no response from Miller or Paxton.
Mark Wingfield argues that Stephen Miller falsely suggested Texas Democratic Senate nominee James Talarico is transgender, and criticizes attacks by Miller and Ken Paxton on Talarico’s identity and personal habits. The column also defends Talarico’s theological comments about God’s gender.
Wingfield says Miller posted that Democrats had nominated their first transgender Senate candidate in Texas, although the columnist says there is no evidence Talarico is transgender. He also describes a separate Miller post about a photo of Talarico eating barbecue as a reference to transgender identity. Wingfield criticizes both posts as smears.
Community verdict
4 VOTESPeople in this story
SWIPE →Texas Democratic Senate nominee responding to attacks about his identity, diet and religious views
President mentioned in connection with Miller and claims about Talarico’s diet
Republican Senate candidate and source of attacks on Talarico
Part of a bigger story
10 OUTLETSStephen Miller called Texas Senate candidate James Talarico transgender, and the Democratic Party responded with an insult. Talarico also defended his comments on gender and LGBTQ+ issues amid campaign attacks. Left-leaning outlets present Miller’s claim as false and center Talarico’s defense of his LGBTQ+ positions. Center outlets emphasize the insulting social-media exchange and Talarico’s past comments, with some coverage also following his exchanges with Ken Paxton. Right-leaning outlets focus on Talarico laughing during a separate discussion of God, treating it as a political liability for Democrats.
- ARTICLES
- 10
- OUTLETS
- 10
- AVG CRED
- 63
- townhall.com · The Bulwark's Tim Miller and James Talarico Discuss God's Genitalia, and Dems Wonder Why They Lose Texas
- Cbs12 · Democratic Party to Stephen Miller: 'Shut up you ugly f**k'
- PinkNews | Latest lesbian, gay, bi and trans news | LGBTQ+ news · Democrats respond as White House staffer says James Talarico is trans
Discussion · 0
Loading comments…


