Morning Joe delivers brutal message to 'stupid liar' Ken Paxton
Scarborough criticized Schmitt for using a text message about Smith’s location despite a warning that it was unverified.

SOURCE CHECK
TAP FOR WHYAlternet is classified as an opinion-oriented publisher, and this article mainly recounts broadcast commentary and references other reporting. The page offers limited evidence of independent verification or competing perspectives.
- Source type — Opinion-oriented source type lowers confidence in neutral editorial framing.
- Track record — The article itself does not provide enough information to assess a broader reporting record.
- Transparency — The author is named, but the article provides limited detail about its own reporting process.
- Author attribution — The byline is identified.
The article includes attributed broadcast quotations and references to other reporting, but largely relays the hosts’ accusations without presenting responses or independent verification of the underlying claims.
HOW WE SCORE ↗The article mostly relays criticism from the “Morning Joe” hosts and other commentators. It does not include responses from the people criticized or substantial counterarguments.
- Source diversity — The sources quoted are commentators discussing the criticized figures; no response from those figures appears.
- Counterarguments presented — No meaningful counterargument or defense is included.
- Loaded language — The headline and article use sharply negative descriptions.
The writing adopts a sharply critical framing of Trump and Republican figures, including in its headline and descriptions of the broadcast. It presents little countervailing perspective.
- Language tone — Uses harsh descriptions and foregrounds insults directed at Republican figures.
- Framing — Organizes the story around criticism of Trump, Paxton and Schmitt.
- Source selection — Relies mainly on comments from the critical television hosts and an aligned commentator.
On “Morning Joe,” Joe Scarborough called Ken Paxton a “stupid liar” after a report said a recording captured Paxton criticizing Donald Trump. Scarborough also accused Eric Schmitt of repeating a false claim about Jack Smith’s whereabouts at a basketball game.
The article recounts comments by Scarborough and other “Morning Joe” hosts. Scarborough linked Republican explanations for election setbacks to rising costs, and criticized Schmitt for using a text message claiming Smith attended an Atlanta Hawks game when he was at an Iowa Hawkeyes game. The article says Schmitt had been warned the messages were not vetted or confirmed.
After Mika Brzezinski read from a report about Paxton, Scarborough called him a liar and said, “Let’s see how it works in November.” The article also recounts criticism of Trump’s television-ratings claims and reports Sam Stein’s view that Trump’s criticism of Paxton in Texas may not help Paxton’s numbers.
Community verdict
2 VOTESPeople in this story
SWIPE →President criticized for claims about costs and television ratings
Trump's version of this story ↗Texas attorney general and Senate candidate criticized over a reported recording
Paxton's version of this story ↗Former president mentioned in a comparison of living costs
Discussion · 0
Loading comments…



