Ken Paxton Can't Even Get His Own Lawyer's Vote
Paxton’s former defense lawyer criticized him and endorsed Democratic Senate nominee James Talarico.

SOURCE CHECK
TAP FOR WHYAbove the Law is an established legal trade publication with an identified author, but this short piece combines sourced reporting with overtly opinionated commentary. It attributes key claims to NOTUS and campaign finance records rather than presenting extensive independent reporting.
- Source type — Legal trade publication with a recognizable niche audience.
- Editorial standards — Some claims are attributed to NOTUS, attorneys, and campaign finance records, though the piece is strongly opinionated.
- Author attribution — The article names its author.
The article includes attributed remarks and a specific campaign-finance detail, but offers little response or broader context and uses openly judgmental commentary. Its reporting is adequate for the narrow endorsement story, though the presentation is not even-handed.
HOW WE SCORE ↗The story centers critical remarks about Paxton and favorable remarks about Talarico, without seeking a response from Paxton. The divorce update includes a statement from his attorneys, but the article adds speculative and mocking commentary.
- Counterarguments presented — No direct response from Paxton is included; his attorneys address the divorce discussions only.
- Source diversity — Quotes Cogdell, Talarico, and Paxton’s attorneys, but the political framing relies chiefly on critics of Paxton.
- Loaded language — The article includes sarcasm and editorial judgments about Paxton and the timing of the divorce proceedings.
The piece uses sarcastic and critical language about Paxton and frames his former lawyer’s endorsement as a pointed rebuke. It presents no countervailing perspective from Paxton.
- Language tone — Uses sarcastic and judgmental phrasing, including “rough go” and “quite the story.”
- Framing — Frames the endorsement as evidence of Paxton’s lack of loyalty from those close to him.
- Source selection — Features critical comments about Paxton and favorable comments about Talarico without a direct Paxton response.
Ken Paxton’s former defense lawyer, Dan Cogdell, endorsed Texas Senate candidate James Talarico after criticizing Paxton’s representation of Texans. Campaign finance records cited in the article show Cogdell donated to both campaigns, and Paxton’s attorneys said his divorce trial was canceled as discussions continued.
The article reports that Dan Cogdell, who previously represented Ken Paxton, is backing Democratic Senate nominee James Talarico. Cogdell told NOTUS that Paxton had “lost sight of his core mission” and said he supported Talarico’s emphasis on unity. Campaign finance records show Cogdell donated $6,500 to Paxton’s campaign last year and $1,000 to Talarico in March. Talarico welcomed support from Republicans, including Paxton’s impeachment lawyer.
The article also notes that Cogdell criticized Donald Trump and that a Republican committee used the remark in an attack ad that was later deleted. Paxton’s attorneys said the June 24 divorce trial had been canceled while the parties pursued an amicable resolution. The article speculates that the cancellation could mean allegations expected to be aired publicly might not be heard.
Community verdict
VOTING CLOSEDNo good or bad look here
This story reports what happened without casting Paxton in a good or bad light, so readers don’t rate it and it doesn’t count toward Paxton’s record.
People in this story
SWIPE →Republican Senate candidate whose former lawyer endorsed his Democratic opponent
Democratic Senate nominee endorsed by Cogdell
Texas senator referenced in Talarico’s statement
Part of a bigger story
8 OUTLETSDan Cogdell, who defended Ken Paxton during his impeachment trial, endorsed James Talarico, Paxton’s opponent in the Texas Senate race, and criticized Paxton. Left-leaning outlets present the endorsement as a repudiation by a former Paxton ally and stress Cogdell’s criticism. Center outlets pair the endorsement and criticism with Paxton campaign pushback and support for him from another former defense lawyer.
- ARTICLES
- 9
- OUTLETS
- 8
- AVG CRED
- 62
Discussion · 0
Loading comments…



